《赵氏孤儿案》评价两极 故事丰满vs假大空台词-看世界

《赵氏孤儿案》评价两极 故事丰满vs假大空台词

  盛赞:故事丰满场景考究

  导读:吴秀波、孙淳携手的电视剧《案》在央视一套首播,虽然只有一集露出真容,但网上对于这部历史正剧的讨论旋即掀起高潮,而网友的评论呈现两极,一边热烈的好评:尤其是吴秀波、孙淳分别饰演的程婴、屠岸贾忠奸对决颇为抢眼球,“孙淳绝对适合老奸巨猾的角色,而波叔收起了锋芒,表演入骨超赞。”不过,该剧同时遭遇网络盗播,导演怒称要维权、“有报应”。

Reading Guide: the TV series "case" jointly produced by Wu Xiubo and Sun Chun was premiered on CCTV. Although only one episode showed its true features, the discussion on this historical drama on the Internet immediately rose to a climax, and the comments of netizens showed two poles, with warm praise on the one hand: in particular, Cheng Ying and tu'an Jia Zhongjian played by Wu Xiubo and Sun Chun were quite eye-catching. "Sun Chun is absolutely suitable for the competition The role of a cunning old man, and uncle Bo put up his sharpness, and his performance was superb. " However, at the same time, the play was stolen from the Internet, and the director angrily said that he wanted to safeguard rights and "have retribution".

  盛赞:故事丰满场景考究

Praise: rich story and exquisite scene

  该戏以晋楚大战开篇,大气磅礴扣人心弦,本来错综复杂的人物关系和背景在将近20分钟里就已讲清楚,程婴、屠岸贾、庄姬公主等人也依次出场。而吴秀波饰演的程婴内敛不张扬颇受好评。相比之下,孙淳是开头最出彩的演员,他出演的屠岸贾一颦一笑、举手投足都是戏,充分刻画了奸臣城府之深、心志之远、气度之大。而之前的超长片花显示吴秀波、孙淳会有大量精彩的对手戏。同时,和吴秀波搭档夫妻的练束梅眼睛充满灵气,在薄薄的戏份里做足了功课,而屠岸贾的幕僚眉宇间的戏份十分抢眼,值得细细品味。

The play begins with the war between Jin and Chu, which is majestic and gripping. The originally complicated relationship and background of the characters have been made clear in nearly 20 minutes, and Cheng Ying, tu'anja, Princess Zhuang Ji and others have also successively appeared. However, Cheng Ying, played by Wu Xiubo, is introverted and not publicized. In contrast, sun Chun is the most brilliant actor at the beginning. Tu'an Jia's every smile and every move is a play, which fully depicts the deep, far-reaching and magnanimous city government of the traitors. And the previous super long films show that Wu Xiubo and sun Chun will have a lot of wonderful rival plays. At the same time, the eyes of Lian Shumei, the partner of Wu Xiubo and her husband and wife, are full of aura, and they have done their homework in the thin part. The part between the eyebrows of tu'an Jia's staff is very eye-catching and worth savoring.

  网友hongli840911:只看了第一集,就有让人眼前一亮的感觉。场景的设计非常的精致,且不说屠岸贾的书房,就连赵朔的马车,都是美轮美奂,异常考据。再说故事情节。之前陈凯歌用两个小时描述这个赵氏孤儿的故事,本片却长达40集,本人不免担心故事情节又臭又长,用一大堆的狗血戏来滥竽充数(比如A爱上B,B其实喜欢C,或者两人真爱却发现原来是兄妹),

Net friend Hong Li 840911: only saw the first episode, has let the human in front of a bright feeling. The design of the scene is very exquisite, not to mention tu'anjia's study, even Zhao Shuo's carriage, are beautiful and unusual textual research. And the story. Chen Kaige used to describe the story of Zhao's orphan in two hours, but the film is 40 episodes long. I can't help worrying that the plot is smelly and long, and I use a lot of dog blood plays to make up the numbers (for example, a falls in love with B, B actually likes C, or the two love each other but find that they are brothers and sisters),

《赵氏孤儿案》剧照

A still photo of Zhao's orphanage

  网友某某某某某了:喜欢《赵氏孤儿案》,它把做人、做事的道理娓娓道来。程婴先去送信再回来救宋香,虽然要做的都是对的事,但是君子会按照先后主次来做,这就是依理智做事,但常人很有可能依情感做事。对于救程婴还是救卑南,庄姬公主和韩厥说的都有道理,但是二者相比,就发现韩厥的话是大道理。

Netizen XX XX: like the case of Zhao's orphan, which tells us the truth of life and work. Cheng Ying delivers the letter first and then comes back to save song Xiang. Although all he has to do is right, the gentleman will do it according to the priority. That is to do things according to reason, but ordinary people are likely to do things according to emotion. Princess Zhuang Ji and Han Jue are both reasonable in saving Cheng Ying or Beinan. However, compared with them, Han Jue's words are quite reasonable.

  吐槽:假大空,编剧水平太差

Tucao: false sky, the screenwriter level is too poor.

  网友无为东周:看了2集,就是编剧水平太差,演员演的还可以。台词也太白话,看着别扭。

Netizen Wuwei Dongzhou: after watching 2 episodes, the level of screenwriters is too poor, and the actors can perform well. The lines are too vernacular. They look awkward.

  1、屠岸贾为什么和赵家有,是源于赵盾弑君这件事,这也跟灵公的腐败相关,隐去了赵盾这段,就少了一个高潮,倒是陈凯歌的电影还提了赵盾。

1. The reason why tu'anjia and Zhao's family have something to do with Zhao Dun's killing the monarch is also related to linggong's corruption. If Zhao Dun is hidden, there will be no climax. Chen Kaige's film also mentions Zhao dun.

  2、公孙忤臼成了侠客,还有程婴的老婆也参合进来,屠岸贾老婆也生小孩,真叫一个乱。真想说拜托这些编剧,能不能不瞎编啊,本来已经写得相当精彩了,瞧这加进来什么乱七八糟的?

2. Gongsun Wu Jiu became a Xiake, and Cheng Ying's wife joined in. Tu'an Jia's wife also gave birth to children. It's really a mess. I really want to say that please these writers, can we not make up the story? It has already been written very well. What's the mess in it?

  3、赵氏孤儿居然养在屠岸贾家里,这个电影和电视一样的处理是最大的败笔,绝对的不可能,能不能不编这些不现实的东西。

3. Zhao's orphan is actually raised in tu'an Jia's house. The same treatment of this film and TV is the biggest failure. It's absolutely impossible. Can we not make up these unrealistic things.

  4、从赵盾和灵公矛盾演起,到刺杀赵盾、赵盾出走,弑君,新国君继位,屠岸贾付出,赵家满门被灭,大肆搜捕赵氏孤儿,程婴、公孙忤臼出头,偷出婴儿,首阳山换婴,抚养赵氏孤儿长大,赵武复出,屠岸贾被灭,这剧本本来可以很紧张紧凑的,这东一点,西一点,编的乱七八糟的,谁还看啊,无语。如果你再知道左传的记载,加上后来晋国被三分,你就觉得一切编的是何等幼稚和可笑。

4. From Zhao Dun's and linggong's contradictory performance to the assassination of Zhao Dun and Zhao Dun's departure, the killing of the monarch, the succession of the new monarch, the payment of tu'an Jia, the destruction of Zhao's family, the wanton search for Zhao's orphans, Cheng Ying and Gongsun Wu Jiu's emergence, the stealing of the baby, the first Yangshan baby change, the raising of Zhao's orphan, the return of Zhao Wu and the extinction of tu'an Jia, this script could have been very tense and compact, this is the east point, West a bit, make up a mess of, who still see, speechless. If you know the records of Zuozhuan and the fact that Jin Kingdom was divided into three parts later, you will find it childish and ridiculous.

免责声明:以上内容源自网络,版权归原作者所有,如有侵犯您的原创版权请告知,我们将尽快删除相关内容。

Disclaimer: the above content comes from the Internet, and the copyright belongs to the original author. If you violate your original copyright, please let us know, and we will delete the relevant content as soon as possible.

本文由 看世界 作者:小小 发表,其版权均为 看世界 所有,文章内容系作者个人观点,不代表 看世界 对观点赞同或支持。如需转载,请注明文章来源。

发表评论