西汉和东汉的评价为什么会两极化 难道是因为汉武帝的缘故吗-看世界

西汉和东汉的评价为什么会两极化 难道是因为汉武帝的缘故吗

  其实把东汉和西汉的时间加在一起,就是中国历史上最长的一个朝代。但人们似乎对西汉的印象会比东汉更加深刻一些,而且评价也会更高。人们提到东汉的时候,往往就是和三国历史联系到了一起,所以东汉的存在感一直不高,想起来的都是最落寞的时刻。为什么人们对西汉和东汉的评价如此两极呢?难道是因为西汉出了一个汉武帝么?实际上汉武帝也没能消灭匈奴,反而是到了东汉才有所改观,难道是我们太忽略东汉所作出的贡献了?

  为何不如西汉,这是很多读者都比较关心的问题,接下来就和各位读者一起来了解,给大家一个参考。

Why is it inferior to the Western Han Dynasty? This is a problem that many readers are concerned about. Next, we will learn from you and give you a reference.

  其实把东汉和西汉的时间加在一起,就是中国历史上最长的一个朝代。但人们似乎对西汉的印象会比东汉更加深刻一些,而且评价也会更高。人们提到东汉的时候,往往就是和历史联系到了一起,所以东汉的存在感一直不高,想起来的都是最落寞的时刻。为什么人们对西汉和东汉的评价如此两极呢?难道是因为西汉出了一个么?实际上汉武帝也没能消灭匈奴,反而是到了东汉才有所改观,难道是我们太忽略东汉所作出的贡献了?

In fact, the time of the Eastern Han Dynasty and the Western Han Dynasty together is the longest Dynasty in Chinese history. But people seem to be more impressed with the Western Han Dynasty than the Eastern Han Dynasty, and the evaluation will be higher. When people refer to the Eastern Han Dynasty, they are often connected with history, so the sense of existence of the Eastern Han Dynasty is not high, and they think of the most lonely moment. Why people's evaluation of the Western Han Dynasty and the Eastern Han Dynasty is so bipolar? Is it because there was one in the Western Han Dynasty? In fact, the Emperor Wudi of the Han Dynasty didn't eliminate the Huns, but it was the Eastern Han Dynasty that made a change. Is it because we ignored the contribution made by the Eastern Han Dynasty?

  匈奴是在西汉被打垮,在东汉走向灭亡的,那么就有一个很奇怪的地方,那就是为什么谈起反击匈奴,大家都在称赞西汉,而对于灭了匈奴的东汉谈论的很少呢?

The Xiongnu was defeated in the Western Han Dynasty and went to extinction in the Eastern Han Dynasty. Then there is a very strange place. That's why when we talk about fighting against Xiongnu, we are all praising the Western Han Dynasty, but we seldom talk about the Eastern Han Dynasty which destroyed Xiongnu?

  首先,西汉是代表了中国最能反抗外侵的标志,先期被人打,而且打的很惨,汉武帝之后,奋力反击,终将匈奴打残,极大的鼓舞了中国的志气。而东汉作为西汉的延伸,在人们的眼里,一直延续着汉民族的荣光,消灭匈奴也就显得顺理成章。没有西汉对匈奴的重创,哪来的东汉消灭匈奴。就好比你吃到第四碗时终于吃饱了,可没有前面三碗饭,又怎会饱呢?

First of all, the Western Han Dynasty is the symbol of China's resistance to foreign invasion. It was beaten in advance, and it was very miserable. After Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty, he fought back and eventually beat the Xiongnu, which greatly encouraged China's ambition. As an extension of the Western Han Dynasty, the Eastern Han Dynasty, in people's eyes, has been continuing the glory of the Han nationality, so it is natural to eliminate the Huns. Without the heavy damage of the Western Han Dynasty to the Huns, how could the Eastern Han Dynasty eliminate them. It's like when you have the fourth bowl, you are finally full, but without the first three bowls of rice, how can you be full?

  这就好比,西汉是一个孱弱少年终于成长为强壮青年并击倒昔日欺压他的流氓,自然为人侧目。东汉是强壮中年把那个已经虚弱的老流氓毫不客气地打个半死,自然没啥好的。汉武帝连续四十余年举国之力,早已经把匈奴打残废了。而且,匈奴是狼性,强大的是首领,弱小了就被别的部落啃食。

For example, in the Western Han Dynasty, a weak young man finally grew up to be a strong young man and beat down the hoodlums who oppressed him in the past, so he was naturally looked at. The Eastern Han Dynasty was strong and middle-aged. It was no good beating the weak old rascal half dead. For more than 40 years, Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty had already disabled the Huns. Moreover, the Huns are wolf like, the strong is the leader, the weak is eaten by other tribes.

  西汉时期,汉武帝连续四十余年用兵,也是国家财力消耗一空。举国上下几乎没有中阶级了。为什么没有呢?你随便翻翻历史书就知道了。这也跟后来汉武帝出名的《轮台赋》有关。既然大汉都打的国家消耗一空,就只有更惨,更悲惨,十分悲惨来形容了。这也就是东汉灭匈奴,史书赞美之词少于西汉的缘故。前期攻打匈奴花费巨大,想想当时连续四十余年国家资源倾向战争,这笔开销是多么巨大。

During the Western Han Dynasty, Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty used his troops for more than 40 years in a row, which also consumed the national financial resources. There is almost no middle class in the whole country. Why not? You can just look through the history books. This is also related to the later famous "Luntai Fu" of Emperor Wu of Han Dynasty. Since all the big men have beaten the country to waste, there is only a more miserable, more miserable, very miserable to describe. This is the reason why the praise words in the historical books were less than those in the Western Han Dynasty. It cost a lot to attack Xiongnu in the early stage. Think about how much it cost to attack Xiongnu for more than 40 years.

  从西汉之后,再无连续对游牧民族用兵四十余年的大战纪录。汉的国威是打出来的。虽然后世多有微词。但是从此之后,华夏以汉为傲,精神一直流传千古。对游牧民族战争,比大明大隋大秦牛,这些朝代即使大胜,都局部胜利,没有对少数民族毁灭性打击。

Since the Western Han Dynasty, there has been no record of war against nomads for more than 40 years. Han's national prestige was fought out. Although there are many micro words in later generations. But since then, Chinese people have been proud of the Han nationality and their spirit has been handed down for thousands of years. The war against the nomadic people was greater than that of the Ming Dynasty, the Sui Dynasty and the Qin Niu Dynasty. Even if these dynasties won a great victory, they won in part and did not have a devastating impact on the ethnic minorities.

  再者西汉重创匈奴是靠自身的实力,而东汉灭北匈奴是联合南匈奴才取得的成就。而且出兵还是以南匈奴为主,东汉为辅。举个简单的例子,买个电冰箱要3000多,西汉自己掏腰包就买了,而东汉出1200,南匈奴出1800,才合力买下了这冰箱。正是西汉重创打击匈奴,使其削弱分裂为南匈奴,北匈奴。用现代的话说就是西汉栽桃树,东汉摘桃子。

Moreover, the Western Han Dynasty made great efforts to defeat Xiongnu by its own strength, while the Eastern Han Dynasty made great achievements by uniting with the southern Xiongnu. In addition, the troops were mainly from the southern Huns, supplemented by the Eastern Han Dynasty. For a simple example, it took more than 3000 yuan to buy a refrigerator. The Western Han Dynasty paid for it, while the Eastern Han Dynasty paid 1200 yuan and the southern Huns 1800 yuan to buy it together. It was the Western Han Dynasty that attacked the Xiongnu so severely that it was weakened and divided into the South Xiongnu and the north Xiongnu. In modern words, peach trees were planted in the Western Han Dynasty and peaches were picked in the Eastern Han Dynasty.

  当然把东汉完全看作是西汉的延续也是不对的,东汉是刘秀在废墟上重新建立起来的一个完完全全新的王朝,东汉队匈奴的巨大军事优势也不是继承西汉的力量,不该被看的理所应当,终东汉一朝,东联日本,西结大秦,到达地中海沿岸,文化昌盛,张衡,,,文化大为发展,确实不应该看作出完全捡了西汉王朝的便宜。

Of course, it's also wrong to regard the Eastern Han Dynasty as the continuation of the Western Han Dynasty. The Eastern Han Dynasty is a completely new dynasty rebuilt by Liu Xiu on the ruins. The great military advantage of the Xiongnu of the Eastern Han Dynasty is not to inherit the power of the Western Han Dynasty, which should not be seen. In the end, the Eastern Han Dynasty, the Eastern Han Dynasty, Japan, the Western Qin Dynasty, the Mediterranean coast, cultural prosperity, Zhang Heng,, The great development of culture really shouldn't be seen as a complete pick-up of the Western Han Dynasty.

免责声明:以上内容源自网络,版权归原作者所有,如有侵犯您的原创版权请告知,我们将尽快删除相关内容。

Disclaimer: the above content comes from the Internet, and the copyright belongs to the original author. If you violate your original copyright, please let us know, and we will delete the relevant content as soon as possible.

本文由 看世界 作者:小小 发表,其版权均为 看世界 所有,文章内容系作者个人观点,不代表 看世界 对观点赞同或支持。如需转载,请注明文章来源。

发表评论